The trend for consultants to form or join group practices is well established. Civica Medical Billing and Collection‘s Simon Brignall looks at the challenges created by scale, and how running a group differs from running a sole practice.

Group practices offer consultants a compelling proposition. Sharing costs can create economies of scale, while bringing consultants together creates opportunities for sub-specialisation, cross-referral and greater capacity. Patients can benefit too, with access to a broader range of expertise within a single practice. 

Some specialties, such as anaesthetics and radiology, naturally favour the group model, particularly when they supply clinical services to a private hospital or an NHS trust. Groups can also improve the quality of care, because several consultants working together in the same specialty, each with their own area of expertise, give patients a more comprehensive service.

For example, a urology group may include a surgeon focused on stone removal working alongside colleagues whose subspecialty is uro-oncology or urogynaecology.

Groups often benefit from increased volume. Insurers and GPs are more likely to refer patients to a centre of excellence that has a wide range of expertise and the capacity to treat them promptly.

But many of these advantages come from scale, and scale brings complexity. As groups grow, so does the administrative burden behind them. More consultants can mean more invoices, different fee structures, more payment pathways and significantly more reconciliation. Without the right infrastructure, some of the benefits of joining a group can quickly be eroded.

Civica Medical Billing and Collection (MBC) has more than 35 years’ experience in the sector and groups have always been a key part of our client base. Civica MBC partners with more than 70 groups across a wide range of specialties, so we understand the problems that arise. Our service helps groups manage these challenges and delivers financial resilience to the practice, while our modern payment solutions improve the patient experience. 

The wisdom of groups

The key points to consider when you set up or join a group

Group structure

The term “group” covers a variety of models. The simplest is the virtual group, where consultants continue to operate as individual practices under common branding, often with a shared website. Admin costs can still be shared, while the group appears as a unified entity to its patients.

More formal structures include chambers, limited liability partnerships and limited companies, often rely on pooled funds. Some have founding partners and rules governing the distribution of funds and the allocation of costs. Other well-established groups require a consultant to hit a revenue target, or work for a set period, before their income and cost allocations are equitable with other members.

When success creates its own challenges

Groups often become victims of their own success. Managing the volume of activity is the single biggest issue they face, and the more successful the group, the bigger the issue becomes. The administration required when consultants work together is routinely underestimated. It covers everything from raising invoices to answering calls and emails, dealing with insurers, clinics and hospitals, and coordinating clinicians.

In our experience, groups set aside reconciliation and chasing first. If you do not know what is outstanding, you cannot raise shortfall invoices in good time or chase the money you are owed. Debt and cashflow suffer and, in some cases, consultants earn less than before they joined the group, which defeats the point. Delays in invoicing affect every stage of the revenue cycle. Problems that could have been resolved early go unnoticed, patients become dissatisfied and income falls.

We’ve seen groups join Civica MBC with hundreds of thousands of pounds outstanding and tens of thousands written off as bad debt. Our robust chase processes and modern payment solutions deliver an average bad debt rate of less than 0.5% across the company, and we’ve seen it as low as 0.08%.

Staffing

Groups are organic. Consultants join and leave, activity fluctuates and different specialties grow at different rates. That makes administrative capacity difficult to predict. Recruit for today’s workload and a growing group can quickly become stretched; recruit ahead of demand and it carries unnecessary fixed cost.

This is a major reason groups choose to partner with Civica Medical Billing and Collection. Our cost model is linked to income received, so we adapt automatically as your requirements change.

One group doesn’t mean one tariff

Consultants’ fees may vary within a group, either by choice or, more commonly, because of their individual contractual terms with private medical insurers (PMIs). Newer consultants are often restricted to set consultation fees by the insurers, while more established colleagues may benefit from higher contracted fees. Self-pay tariffs can also vary. Depending on the hospital or procedure, they may be collected directly from the patient or as part of a fixed-price package.

The group must keep accurate records of each clinician’s price structure and payment pathways, while keeping up with changes to each insurer’s schedule and to the Clinical Coding Schedule and Development (CCSD) schedule. Billing errors cause income losses, delayed payments, recoups and, in the worst cases, derecognition. Civica MBC’s proprietary billing software and UK-based dedicated account management let us tailor our service to the specific needs of your group.

Bank accounts

Payment arrangements depend on the model a group adopts. Formal structures generally use one pooled bank account, although this is not always the case, while virtual models keep the money separate. Insurance billing is typically processed under each consultant’s individual provider number, so the money flows to the associated bank account. In every scenario, you must identify each payment correctly and allocate it to the right consultant, especially where onward payments are needed.

Consultants who also practise outside the group need particular care. You need robust procedures to transfer payments and share remittances. Payments often go to the wrong account, and we’ve taken on groups that had missed out on income for years as a result. At Civica MBC, we’re well versed in managing consultants whose activity is split between their own practice and the group.

Visibility is key

As groups become larger and more complex, visibility becomes increasingly important. Leaders need to understand not only the financial position of the group as a whole, but what is happening at clinician level: activity, payments, outstanding debt and emerging problems. Without that visibility, issues can remain hidden until they affect cashflow or consultant income.

Our reporting Dashboard recreates the group’s structure, giving you real-time reporting at both group and clinician level for income, activity, payments and aged debt. We also offer tiered access if you want to limit the information each consultant can see.

Making the most of the group model

As this article shows, groups offer many benefits, but you can lose them if you don’t manage the issues that arise effectively. We work as a long-term partner invested in your outcomes, not just your invoices. If you run a group or are considering starting one, find out how Civica Medical Billing and Collection can support you.

Simon Brignall is Head of Sales and Accounts at Civica Medical Billing and Collection.